Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0Visa Gives Merchants More Power to Stop Friendly Fraud
In a Nutshell
A new initiative from Visa known as Compelling Evidence 3.0 (or “CE3.0” for short) makes it easier for merchants to prevent fraudulent chargebacks and avoid revenue loss. In this article, we’ll take a close look at Visa CE3.0, including how it works, the situations where it will have the most impact, and how it can supercharge the prevention capabilities of Order Insight.
Is Your Business Ready for Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0?
You may imagine that, somewhere in an issuer’s operations centre, a cardholder is on the phone right this moment about a charge from your store.
The analyst taking the call has a queue, a turnaround target, and a drop-down menu. The sale was a card-absent transaction, conducted with a Visa card, and cardholder says it was not authorised. By all available indicators, that claim should be filed under reason code 10.4: Other Fraud — Card-absent Environment.
Before 2023, that claim would have been a fairly open-and-shut case. Now Visa’s system asks a question first: has this card bought from this merchant before, twice, without complaint? If the data lines up, the dispute may not be filed.
That check is performed under Compelling Evidence 3.0. In this post, I’ll walk you through what qualifies, how to submit it, and what Visa has changed since CE3.0 first launched.
What is Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0?
- Compelling Evidence 3.0
Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0 is a set of guidelines and evidence requirements for disputes. It provides a standardized framework for all parties involved in the chargeback process, enabling merchants to substantiate claims by sharing real-time information, and prevent disputes marked with Visa reason code 10.4.
[noun]/kəm • pel • iNG • ev • ə • d • ns/
Cardholders have the right to dispute unauthorized charges on their credit card statements. There are times, however, when a disputed transaction is actually valid: the customer may have called the bank in error, or they may be trying to game the system to engage in cyber-shoplifting. In either case, chargebacks filed without legitimate cause are considered first-person misuse, or “friendly fraud.”
Visa’s core rules (effective as of April 2023) have now introduced Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0 in response to this problem. This new ruleset expands the list of compelling evidence you can use to help undo an invalid customer dispute. In many instances, updated guidelines and parameters will be able to automatically identify a dispute as invalid and block it.
The new rules center on historical purchase evidence. If a merchant can provide evidence that certain elements (device fingerprint, IP address, etc.) used in the transaction being disputed were also associated with two previously undisputed transactions, the fraud claim will be denied.
CE3.0 was implemented to make the representment process more efficient, transparent, and fair. It specifically applies to disputes filed under Visa reason code 10.4: Other Fraud — Card-Absent Environment. This reason code is often associated with friendly fraud due to its generic, open-ended nature.
Compelling Evidence 3.0 only affects claims filed under Visa reason code 10.4 (Other Fraud — Card-absent Environment). Click here to learn more about Visa reason code 10.4.
What are the Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0 Qualification Criteria?
The CE3.0 rule set allows you to produce two previous transactions in response to a dispute. Neither of these transactions may have been reported as fraud by the issuer. Both must have been processed more than 120 days — and no more than 365 days — before the dispute.
Two data points from those earlier transactions must match the disputed one, drawn from four options: the customer’s account or login ID, the full delivery address, the device ID or fingerprint, and the IP address. One of the two must be either the device ID or the IP. You also need an item description for all three transactions.
Just reading about it can make it seem a little confusing. So, here’s a side-by-side look at the old and new rules:
| Before April 2023 | After CE3.0 Rollout | |
| Number of prior purchases (undisputed) | 1 | 2 |
| Items required to match between prior undisputed purchases and transaction in question | All of the following: IP address, Email address, Physical (shipping) address, Telephone number | At least two of the following: Customer account/login ID, Delivery address, Device ID/device fingerprint, IP address (one of the two must be the device or the IP) |
| Time frame for undisputed transactions used as evidence | None | Processed more than 120 days, and no more than 365 days, before the dispute |
| Submission | In dispute response | Either pre-dispute or in the dispute response |
Visa previously accepted email address and phone number as viable evidence. However, these no longer count.
What Evidence Does Visa Accept for CE3.0 Data Elements?
You know the categories of acceptable evidence. What about the specific documentation? The table below outlines this in more detail:
| Data element | What Visa requires |
| Customer account or login ID | The ID the cardholder signs in with, in clear text, not hashed. Since Oct. 24, 2026, an agentic payment provider login also counts. |
| Full delivery address | Street, city, state or province, postal code, and country, in clear text. |
| Device ID | A serial number, IMEI, or similar identifier the cardholder could verify; at least 15 characters, in clear text. |
| Device fingerprint | Built from at least two device properties (browser version, operating system version); at least 20 characters, may be hashed. Device ID and fingerprint count as one element; you can’t use both. |
| IP address | The cardholder’s public IP address, IPv4 or IPv6, in clear text. |
There are two exceptions here. First, the 120-day minimum doesn’t apply when the earlier transactions were original credit transactions. Second, Visa matches on the underlying card number, so tokenized purchases do count.
Subscription merchants get one accommodation. The IP address captured on the customer’s first sign-up transaction can be reused as the matching element for the recurring charges that follow. The two earlier charges still have to fall inside the 120- to 365-day window, which is why a merchant billing once a year can’t qualify for this protection.
Two purchases, two tests
CE3.0 works only when two earlier purchases on the same card pass both tests: they’re the right age, and their data matches the disputed purchase.
Chargeback rules change constantly
With Chargebacks911® in your corner, you're never caught off guard
Request a Demo
What Did CE3.0 Replace?
As I mentioned, fighting any dispute hinges on compelling evidence. But what makes any given piece of evidence “compelling?”
According to Visa rules, compelling evidence is information that attempts to prove the cardholder participated in the transaction, received the goods or services, or otherwise benefited from it. The documents that constitute compelling evidence are predetermined based on the type of chargeback in question.
Before April 2023, a merchant challenging a reason code 10.4 chargeback could point to one earlier purchase, and all of the following data elements would have to match it:
- IP Address
- Email Address
- Physical Address
- Telephone Number
Even then, a full match was only a ticket to argue; it still didn’t guarantee a reversal. In fact, if this was the only proof you had, the odds of winning the case would be low.
Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0 was developed as a way of helping merchants mitigate losses to invalid disputes. In many cases, this can be done before the dispute is filed.
That older style of evidence hasn’t gone away: Visa’s rules still let you cite three or more of six matching items (login ID, delivery address, device, email, IP, phone) from an earlier undisputed purchase. But, that remains evidence that the issuer may choose to evaluate during representment; it’s not the automatic remedy CE3.0 gives you.
How Do You Submit CE3.0 Evidence?
Working through Order Insight, you can block a false dispute before it’s filed and avoid the chargeback altogether. Since Oct. 17, 2025, Visa has allowed something similar for transactions authenticated through Visa Secure.
Working through either Order Insight or Visa Secure is the best approach. But, even if neither apply to the transaction in question, CE3.0 still gives you a clean way to fight the chargeback after the fact.
The table below compares the pre- and post-dispute processes:
| If information is submitted before the dispute is filed, then… | If information is submitted after the dispute is filed, then… |
| The dispute never gets filed. | You may respond through your acquirer as a pre-arbitration case. |
| The claim can’t escalate to a dispute. | The issuer has 30 days to accept or contest; arbitration is still possible. |
| There’s no monetary loss and no fees. | Chargeback fees still apply. |
| It doesn’t affect your Visa Acquirer Monitoring Program (VAMP) ratio. | The dispute counts until reversed; may be excluded afterward depending on your acquirer’s reporting. |
Before the Dispute Is Filed
The cardholder calls. The analyst codes the claim as a 10.4 and tries to raise the dispute. Before it goes anywhere, Visa checks for earlier purchases on the same card at your business that nobody reported as fraud.
If you’re enrolled in Order Insight, you get an inquiry asking for the matching data elements on two of those purchases. You send them back. Order Insight validates the data and passes it to Visa, and if the criteria are met, the dispute is blocked and liability stays with the issuer.
For transactions that ran through Visa Secure, the same check can happen with no inquiry at all, because Visa already holds the authentication data.
After the Chargeback Is Filed
The route runs through your acquirer, as a pre-arbitration case in Visa Resolve Online (VROL). You identify two earlier purchases by the same cardholder, inside the 120- to 365-day window, and hand over the matching data elements plus the item descriptions.
VROL checks the data elements, and an incomplete or incorrect submission is declined; your acquirer can resubmit for a different reason, but not on CE3.0 grounds. If the data holds up, the case goes to the issuer, which has 30 calendar days to accept liability, let the clock run out, or decline with new information and take it to arbitration.
So a filed chargeback is still worth fighting under CE3.0, and your odds are better than they were. You’ll still pay the chargeback fee, and the dispute counts against your VAMP ratio until it’s reversed; whether it comes out afterward depends on how your acquirer reports it.
Learn more about Order InsightHow Order Insight works
From the cardholder’s call to the final outcome: the two ways Visa can block a 10.4 dispute, and what happens when it can’t.
What Has Changed Since CE3.0 Launched?
CE3.0 took effect for pre-arbitration cases on April 15, 2023. Visa has made several updates since:
What’s changed since 2023
Three updates since launch: who runs the check, what it costs, and which purchases and data count.
Advantages of Visa CE 3.0
CE3.0 helps to promote transparency and accountability by requiring that all parties adhere to these guidelines. Issuers and acquirers are held to the same standards when evaluating a chargeback dispute, ensuring a more level playing field for all parties.
Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0 benefits for merchants with qualifying transactions include:
Fewer Overall Chargebacks
A lack of insight into transaction details is what allows friendly fraud to happen. The opportunity to present evidence earlier can decrease the number of friendly fraud chargebacks you receive.
Lower Chargeback Rate
Preventing 10.4 chargebacks will help lower your chargeback rate, as well as your fraud rate. Your dispute ratio won’t be artificially elevated from invalid claims.
Protected Revenue
Fraudulent disputes are typically deflected without the need for a merchant refund. You can also avoid loss of merchandise and chargeback fees.
Faster Resolutions
CE3.0 allows the submission of evidence during the dispute stage. In this way, false claims are deflected in real time.
Simplified Representments
To be fair, representment is never easy. But, with Visa CE3.0 rules in place, you have a wider array of tools for contesting fraud and recovering revenue.
Compelling Evidence 3.0 can help merchants and financial institutions better handle and resolve disputes. However, it's essential to recognize that CE3.0 can’t be a “one-size-fits-all” solution.
Where Does CE3.0 Not Help?
CE3.0 is a real step forward against first-party misuse. There are a few drawbacks that I want to highlight, though.
The first is cost. Since April 17, 2026, every successful qualification carries a Visa fee, set by Visa and passed through by your acquirer. The second is reach; with a new buyer, the historical data that CE3.0 would rely upon doesn’t exist yet. The two earlier purchases have to be more than 120 days old. Also, CE3.0 has no application for a dispute filed under any reason code other than 10.4.
.The third is fit. If you’ve been billing the same card the same amount every single month, finding matching transactions should be easy. CE3.0 could be a huge help in these situations. A merchant whose customers buy once and move on will qualify far less often, though. CE3.0 is a solid foundation, but for the average merchant, it will only help with a subset of disputes. The rest of them still need a broader approach to managing chargebacks.
What Should I Do Now?
If you’re looking to get the most out of Compelling Evidence 3.0, here are a few tips that I would recommend:

The value of chargeback help from Chargebacks911 isn’t limited to CE3.0 implementation. Our experts can help you discover the true sources of all your chargebacks and help you implement a comprehensive chargeback management strategy to retain revenue and prevent future disputes.
Ready to get started? Or, just want to learn how much you stand to save? Contact us today to learn more.
FAQs
What are compelling evidence 3.0 dispute rules?
Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0 is a set of guidelines and evidence requirements that merchants and acquirers can use to strengthen their cases when responding to chargebacks. CE3.0 provides a standardized framework for all parties involved in the chargeback process to share information and substantiate their claims.
What is considered compelling evidence?
Under Visa’s rules, compelling evidence is information that attempts to prove the cardholder participated in the transaction, received the goods or services, or otherwise benefited from it. Under CE3.0, this has been updated to include previous undisputed purchases from the same cardholder.
What are the data elements for CE3.0?
Acceptable data elements for CE3.0 include the customer’s user ID, IP address, shipping address, or device ID. One of the two required data items must include either the IP address or the device ID/fingerprint.
What is compelling evidence for fighting chargebacks?
Certain evidence and information will always be necessary, such as customer name, email and billing addresses, service descriptions and receipts. Other specifics may vary based on the reason code. Compelling Evidence 3.0 only affects claims filed under Visa reason code 10.4 (Other Fraud: Card-Absent Environment).
Can Visa's Compelling Evidence 3.0 rules be used without Order Insight?
Yes. Since October 2025, Visa automatically applies CE3.0 to disputes on transactions authenticated through Visa Secure, with no Order Insight inquiry involved. For everything else, CE3.0 applies after the chargeback is filed, as a pre-arbitration case through your acquirer, where chargeback fees and other merchant costs still apply.
What changed in CE3.0 in 2025 and 2026?
From Oct. 17, 2025, Visa automatically qualifies Visa Secure transactions. From April 17, 2026, each successful qualification carries a fee. From Oct. 24, 2026, the two prior purchases can come from other merchants on your acquirer.