The State of Chargebacks 2018

January 30, 2018 | 2 min read

State of Chargebacks

Separating Chargeback Fact from Fiction in the New Study from Kount® & Chargebacks911®

Information on chargebacks is notoriously hard to come-by.

Chargeback reason codes often mask friendly fraud, rather than genuine criminal fraud because outdated, inconsistent policies make it hard to track information and dispute cases. Few merchants possess vital knowledge of complex regulations and chargeback history to identify dispute triggers or create effective cases.

Even Visa Claims Resolution and other new policies will lead to problems, as merchants don't know how to apply tools like Visa Resolve Online effectively.

We already have a chaotic environment with unevenly applied and enforced rules. Unfortunately, constant updates to legal framework governing the industry, such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), means the problem is only going to get worse.

In response, we at Chargebacks911 teamed-up with our partners at Kount to produce The State of Chargebacks 2018 survey. This comprehensive study consulted with dozens of merchants in a variety of industries and product categories to answer a few key questions:

  • How many chargebacks does the average merchant experience?
  • Where are these disputes coming from?
  • Are merchants fighting their chargebacks?
  • Are merchants winning their chargeback disputes?
  • What proactive steps are merchants taking against chargebacks?
The State of Chargebacks 2018

The State of Chargebacks 2018

Launched as a way of collecting and analyzing industry findings, the State of Chargebacks survey reflects the experiences of more than one thousand respondents in the card-not-present space. Download to learn the latest insights on fraud and chargeback management.

Free Download

Our VP of Partner Relations Nate Foss went into deeper detail with these questions in our State of Chargebacks 2018 webinar with Don Bush and Melayna Gabiou of Kount. Don’t worry—even if you didn’t get a chance to catch it live, you can download a recorded version of the complete webinar here. We’ve also pulled some of the most eye-opening stats and chargeback facts down below:

8 Lessons From

The 2018 State of

Chargebacks

The 2018 Chargeback Study From

&

Lesson

1

Merchants are fighting back

8

10

Out Of

Merchants dispute at least some

illegitimate chargebacks

Lesson

2

Merchants are losing the fight

Of the diverse group of merchants

surveyed only 18% reported an

average win rate above 60% when

disputing friendly fraud.

18%

Win Most

Disputes

3

Lesson

Most favor in-house dispute management

In a likely related stat, nearly three quarters of merchants preferred to manage disputes in-house.

Lesson

4

Fraud management is a team effort

Number of People on Internal Fraud and Prevention Teams

Less than 2

3 - 4

More than 5

> $250M

17%

25%

59%

$100M - $250M

38%

33%

29%

$25M - $100M

42%

33%

25%

$10M - $25M

44%

36%

19%

< $10M

77%

19%

5%

10%

Lesson

5

Merchants rely on experts

Half of the merchants surveyed who were

involved in fraud prevention relied on third

party tools.

Using 3rd Party Fraud Solution

Not Using 3rd Party Fraud Solution

45%

45%

Don’t Know

Lesson

6

Merchants identify CNP fraud as largest threat

Despite evidence indicating that friendly fraud is often the greater threat, nearly half of all merchants still remain focused on criminal fraud.

28%

7%

4%

48%

12%

1%

Friendly

Fraud

Account

Takeover

Merchant

Error

CNP Fraud

Don’t Know

Other

Lesson

7

59%

Disputing chargebacks is challenging

Disputing Chargebacks

58%

Merchants were asked to identify their top 3 biggest challenges regarding chargeback management. More than half of respondents listed disputing illegitimate chargebacks as one of their top challenges.

Identifying Friendly Fraud

50%

Decreasing My Chargeback Rate

Lesson

8

Many merchants are “high-risk”

1 in 4 merchants reported a chargeback rate >1%

Which would label them as being a high-risk

merchant by the card schemes

 

The State of Chargebacks

2018 Chargeback Study

DOWNLOAD THE FREE REPORT

by

&

8 Lessons From

The 2018 State of

Chargebacks

The 2018 Chargeback Study From

&

Lesson

1

Merchants are fighting back

Merchants dispute at least some

illegitimate chargebacks

8

10

Out Of

2

Lesson

Merchants are losing the fight

18%

Of the diverse group of merchants

surveyed only 18% reported an

average win rate above 60% when

disputing friendly fraud.

Win Most

Disputes

Lesson

3

Most favor in-house dispute management

In a likely related stat, nearly three quarters of merchants preferred to manage disputes in-house.

Lesson

4

Fraud management is a team effort

Number of People on Internal Fraud and Prevention Teams

5%

19%

25%

19%

29%

36%

59%

33%

33%

25%

44%

17%

38%

42%

77%

> $250M

$100M - $250M

$25M - $100M

$10M - $25M

< $10M

Less than 2

3 - 4

More than 5

10%

Lesson

5

Merchants rely on experts

Half of the merchants surveyed who were involved in fraud prevention relied on third party tools.

45%

45%

Using 3rd Party Fraud Solution

Not Using 3rd Party Fraud Solution

Don’t Know

Lesson

6

Merchants identify CNP fraud as largest threat

Despite evidence indicating that friendly fraud is often the greater threat, nearly half of all merchants still remain focused on criminal fraud.

28%

7%

4%

48%

12%

1%

Friendly

Fraud

Account

Takeover

Merchant

Error

CNP Fraud

Don’t Know

Other

59%

Lesson

7

Disputing Chargebacks

Disputing chargebacks is challenging

58%

Merchants were asked to identify their top 3 biggest challenges regarding chargeback management. More than half of respondents listed disputing illegitimate chargebacks as one of their top challenges.

Identifying Friendly Fraud

50%

Decreasing

My Chargeback Rate

Lesson

8

Many merchants are “high-risk”

1 in 4 merchants reported a chargeback rate >1%

Which would label them as being a high-risk

merchant by the card schemes

 

The State of Chargebacks

2018 Chargeback Study

DOWNLOAD THE FREE REPORT

by

&

8 Lessons From

The 2018 State of

Chargebacks

The 2018 Chargeback Study From

&

Lesson

1

Merchants are fighting back

8

10

Out Of

Merchants dispute at least some

illegitimate chargebacks

2

Lesson

Merchants are losing the fight

18% Win Most Disputes

Of the diverse group of merchants surveyed only 18% reported an average win rate above 60% when disputing friendly fraud.

Lesson

3

Most favor in-house dispute management

In a likely related stat, nearly three quarters of merchants preferred to manage disputes in-house.

4

Lesson

Fraud management is a team effort

Number of People on Internal Fraud and Prevention Teams

> $250M

$100M - $250M

$25M - $100M

$10M - $25M

< $10M

Less than 2

3 - 4

More than 5

Lesson

5

Merchants rely on experts

10%

Half of the merchants surveyed who were involved in fraud prevention relied on third party tools.

45%

45%

Using 3rd Party Fraud Solution

Not Using 3rd Party Fraud Solution

Don’t Know

Lesson

6

Merchants identify CNP fraud as largest threat

Despite evidence indicating that friendly fraud is often the greater threat, nearly half of all merchants still remain focused on criminal fraud.

48% CNP Fraud

28% Friendly Fraud

12% Don’t Know

7% Account Takeover

4% Merchant Error

1% Other

Lesson

7

Disputing chargebacks is challenging

59%

Disputing Chargebacks

58%

Identifying Friendly Fraud

Decreasing My

Chargeback Rate

50%

Merchants were asked to identify their top 3 biggest challenges regarding chargeback management. More than half of respondents listed disputing illegitimate chargebacks as one of their top challenges.

Lesson

8

Many merchants are “high-risk”

1 in 4 merchants reported

a chargeback rate >1%

Which would label them as being a high-risk

merchant by the card schemes

 

The State of Chargebacks

2018 Chargeback Study

DOWNLOAD THE FREE REPORT

by

&

Copy the Below Code to Embed This Responsive Infographic
<script src="https://chargebacks911.com/embeds/cb911-infographic.js" data-slug="state-of-chargebacks-2018-lp"></script>

This is some valuable info…but it also raises new questions. For example, if 4 out of 5 merchants dispute their chargebacks, why are so few achieving their goals in terms of chargeback mitigation? In many cases, it’s because merchants simply don’t have the insight necessary to handle chargebacks effectively.

In the report, merchants suggest 55% of their chargebacks come from criminal fraud sources like account takeover and identity fraud. In reality, our data suggests 60-80% of chargebacks should be friendly fraud.

How is it possible that what merchants believe is so far-off from the data? Click below to speak with one of our experts and find out.

Like What You're Reading? Join our newsletter and stay up to date on the latest in payments and eCommerce trends.
Newsletter Signup
We’ll run the numbers; You’ll see the savings.
triangle shape background particle triangle shape background particle triangle shape background particle
Please share a few details and we'll connect with you!
Revenue Recovery icon
Over 18,000 companies recovered revenue with products from Chargebacks911
Close Form